In keeping with my new tradition (which I predict will expire sometime
in 2027 for reasons that should be obvious), here are three great albums
released in 1975 to celebrate the fact that we are reviewing our 1,975th
album.
- Bob Dylan, “Blood on the Tracks” (Disc 233)
- Queen, “A Night at the Opera” (Disc 326)
- Alice Cooper, “Welcome to My Nightmare” (Disc 449)
This next record took an extra day to listen to. Was it worth my time? Is it worth yours? Well, to quote Merlin in the movie Excalibur, “Looking into the cake is like looking into the future. Until you’ve tasted it you don’t know what it holds. And then of course, it’s too late.”
Disc 1975 is…Black Widow
Artist: In This Moment
Year of Release: 2014
What’s up with the Cover? I always appreciate an outfit that shows off a little leg but this is not a little leg. In fact, to suggest that this is actually what frontwoman Maria Brink’s leg looks like is…wait for it…a stretch.
How I Came To Know It: My coworker’s niece was into this band and he passed it along as a recommendation. I don’t like everything In This Moment does, but I have fallen for a few of their albums.
This was not initially one them, but I saw it just sitting there at the record store staring up at me, all legs and claws and attitude, daring me to give it a chance. Reader, I succumbed.
How It Stacks Up: I have four In This Moment records. “Black Widow” comes in at #3, which doesn’t bode well for the one I haven’t reviewed yet, but here’s hoping I’m wrong.
Ratings: 2 stars but almost 3
“Black Widow” has its moments, but in many ways it is a pale imitation of In This Moment’s best record (2012’s “Blood” reviewed at Disc 1684). It does a lot of the same things in a lot of the same ways, but it doesn’t consistently land like its predecessor. I bought it hoping it would grow on me, but it was not to be.
Like “Blood” it features industrial Goth metal, a style that is what In This Moment does best. Vocalist lead singer Maria Brink is still a powder keg of emotion, and the band is the same lineup as “Blood” and still more than capable of delivering tight crunchy metal grooves that scrape at your innards. So far, so good.
After a pointless bit of “mood drone” on an intro track best forgotten, the record gets going. “Sex Metal Barbie” is Brink at her best, deliberately provocative and powerful; owning her own sexuality and daring the listener to judge so she can call out the hypocrisy of it all. This is a common In This Moment theme, and they do it well.
In This Moment also loves a lot of production tricks, and “Sex Metal Barbie” dials that stuff up to 11, with all kinds of record skip action, layers and layers of who-knows-what and general busy-ness. There are many places on this record where this doesn’t work, but here it does.
The next track, “Big Bad Wolf” is also a winner. The guitar riff is a bit Nu Metal for my comfort level, but when Maria Brink growls out her refrain of “even in these chains you can’t stop me” with increasing intensity, it is hard not to want to doff your tarp and mosh about in oversized shorts. Being as I was, in the car on the way to work, I refrained.
Unfortunately the strength of these songs doesn’t reflect through the rest of the record. It is a lot of the same kind of sound, but the tracks aren’t compelling and Brink – at her best when she’s got a bit of anguish in her vocals – overdoes it and loses authenticity in the process.
The record isn’t terrible, but the rawness that helped “Blood” push through the production and stab you in the heart is blunted by poppier elements that aren’t as good a fit with Brink’s vocal style.
By the time “Bloody Creature Poster Girl” came along at Track 8, I was feeling a bit of the “Oh, this again” which isn’t the effect a record should have on you. Better is “Natural Born Sinner” at Track 11, which shows off Brink’s ability to deliver a righteous rant, and to remind us – as the saying goes – “don’t judge me because I sin differently than you.” Amen.
Unfortunately, this brief uplift is followed by a two-and-a-half-minute bit of “acting” that dissolves into a full minute’s worth of nothing but a woman sobbing loudly. It may not sound that long, but a minute is a very long time to listen to just sobbing.
The six and a half minute “Out of Hell” then closes out the record with a lot of overwrought gut-wrenching. I liked that the band opts to strip the production down at the end to mostly just Brink’s voice and piano (plus a bunch of police sirens). Singing with honesty and vulnerability is the best way to pull the heartstrings, but there’s a line past which it can actually interfere with the story, and that’s what happens here. Brink overcooks the delivery of what should be a serious and even uplifting message. The result is less true despair, and more of an awkward pat on the back and an obligatory “there there” as you hope – in vain – that the sobbing will stop soon.
“Black Widow” needed to be more aggressive in cutting songs that feel like filler. The record is 13 tracks and a full hour long and feels it. Just three fewer songs and 15 minutes less would have made all the difference.
So, by the narrowest of margins, I must reluctantly part company with this record and send it to a home that will love it better than I was able.
Best tracks: Sex Metal Barbie, Big Bad Wolf, Sick Like Me, Natural Born Sinner

No comments:
Post a Comment