Welcome back. Today I review a good record, and then a great concert.
Disc 1909 is… I Believe In You, My Honeydew
Artist: Josh RitterYear of Release: 2025
What’s up with the Cover? I also used to take my bow out in the woods as a young boy, but there are a couple of key facts that let you know this kid is Josh Ritter, and not me.
First, this kid is wearing shorts. As a kid outside of gym class, I never wore shorts. I didn’t like ‘em. I think they’re fine now, provided it’s warm enough out, but I’m still against sandals. On this latter point this kid version of Josh and I agree.
Second, I had a way more impressive head of hair than this kid. Sorry Josh, but my hair ruled as a kid. It ain’t now what it used to be but back in the day my curls were so big and tight they could repel rainwater.
How I Came To Know It: I’m a fan and so I always check out Josh Ritter albums. I don’t always like them, but since I knew I was going to see him on this album’s tour, it was a safe bet I’d buy the record. And here we are!
How It Stacks Up: I have six Josh Ritter albums. He has thirteen albums, so as you can guess, he’s not an “always” thing for me. “I Believe In You…” is on the edge, so I’ll rank it sixth. Last in my current collection, but still middle of the pack overall.
Ratings: 3 stars
I like my Ritter on the folksy side, with the production a little undercooked. Ritter likes his folk on the rocky side, with his production varied and unpredictable. There are whole records where he pushes me too far and I must wag my finger at full arm extension, as I tilt my head back imperiously and declare, “You cut that out! I won’t buy it, Josh, I won’t!”
His latest release, “I Believe In You, My Honeydew” is, fortunately, not such a record. It has much to recommend it, but is still a microcosm of the Ritter experience, as he slides in and out of styles and tries on different arrangements like a royal in a fancy hat store.
The opening track “You Won’t Dig My Grave” is ground zero for Ritter, with its urgent half-spoken, half-sung style and a mix of electric guitar and piano trilling away in a style that would make Bruce Hornsby proud. It’s solid, but not a “must have” situation – particularly for a fellow who has already shown clear evidence that Ritter and I have a relationship that is on-again, off-again by nature.
The next song (“Honeydew (No Light)”) has a groove that tried very hard but doesn’t quite land (it is hard to funk up the folk and should be attempted only with great caution). When the reverb guitar and feedback/record scratch sounds start popping into the bridge I could feel my wagging finger rising, unbidden, from my side.
But then, on track three Josh Ritter does what he does – dropping one of the finest songs he’s ever done. “Truth Is a Dimension (Both Invisible and Blinding)” is what will always and eternally bring me back into Ritter’s orbit.
Held together by just the deliberate pluck of a single acoustic guitar, “Truth Is a Dimension…” is the narrative of a man who smokes a J, and while stargazing discovers intelligent life in the universe. Well, that’s the bones of it anyway.
In fact, it is so much more. This is a song about life, the subjective nature of truth, the impact of the observer on the observed (both externally on the world, and internally on our thoughts). It muses on the nature of the multiverse but eventually comes around to only one certainty: there’s love, there’s loss, and there’s great art – and that’s the truth.
After a relatively shaky start Josh now had me and he wasn’t going to let go. Does he go back again to that half-funky/groovy thing he does which sometimes works and sometimes feels like the musical equivalent of a smirk? Yes, he does. When you’re as gifted a songwriter as Ritter, you’ll always ride the line between smart and smart-ass. Ask Dylan. He won’t answer the question directly, but he knows.
And some of that frantic approach to the record that I had earlier viewed askance I now better appreciated for the range it was providing. As the record progressed some of the excess energy took on a decidedly church-like quality, aided by Ritter’s careful and considered use of religious iconography on songs like “Noah’s Children” and the refrain of “I hear a higher calling” on “Wild Ways”.
This pulpit-like approach culminates on the record’s final track, “The Throne” which channels greats like Nick Cave and Leonard Cohen at their most devout. Ritter holds up well with these masters. Were there some merely OK tracks between “Truth is a Dimension…” and “the Throne”? Sure there were, but in the glare of the church chords of the piano and the rock peel of the electric guitar, Ritter dispenses wise and inspired observations about life, and once again all is forgiven.
Josh Ritter is a great songwriter, but he’s not one for chasing empty crowd pleasers. His albums can go a lot of directions, and not all of those directions are going to tickle your fancy. Always brilliant and occasionally annoying, “I Believe In You, My Honeydew” was an acquired taste, laden with five-star brilliance and two-star filler. But damn it if on balance the old master didn’t win me over again.
Best tracks: Truth Is a Dimension (Invisible and Blinding), Noah’s Children, Wild Ways, The Throne
The Concert: March 19, 2026, Mary Winspear Centre, Sidney, BC
Heading out to Sidney with Sheila and our friend Casey (kudos to him for driving us), I wasn’t sure what to expect. I knew I liked Josh Ritter, but I wasn’t always keen on his production choices. But as I walked into the plush and cozy 300-seat of the small-town auditorium and saw two single acoustic guitars perched behind some Christmas lights and a lone microphone stand, I knew all was going to be well.
Thing weren’t just well, however – this ended up being one of the best concerts I have ever seen. Ritter is a born entertainer and with a stable of impressive and expressive songs built across two and a half decades, he’s got the ammunition to go with it.
The first thing that jumped out at me was Ritter’s pure and unconditional joy at just being there. His grin is infectious and the first words out of his mouth were to indicate just how thrilled he was to be performing for us. It wasn’t one of those “how are we doing tonight, Sidney?” pandering moments, either. He was happy to be there, and it showed.
Lacking a band did not prevent Ritter from creating layers of sound. He wields his guitar with a busker’s skill for making percussion, with slaps on the body and well-placed hammer-ons on the fretboard. He stepped in and out of the mic as well, creating all manner of sound while never losing that clean acoustic sound I was hoping for.
His guitars were worn and well-used, with pick guards down to the raw wood. They looked well-loved and fit right in with Ritter’s casual and unassuming style.
As for the songs, he played almost every one of my favourites from the new record (the only absence was “Noah’s Children” and frankly, of the four favourites listed above, it is #4). The others weren’t just played, they were elevated, making me love the latest record in ways I hadn’t during the studio listen.
The old standards were well chosen, and he had a knack for mixing slow contemplative pieces in with bangers, moving the energy up and down while never losing the room. A couple of times he appeared to chose a song on the spur of the moment, exclaiming “I just had an idea!” and then giving that idea a go.
The banter was also first rate, always giving additional flavour and energy to the performance and never just resorting to “explaining” a song. When he played his classic hit “Kathleen” he actually took an extended break mid-tune to tell a hilarious yarn, before returning to the final verse, showing that there is a way to keep a song fresh, even if you’ve played it a hundred times.
This was one of those shows that elevated the spirit. At times you lose yourself in Ritter’s imagery and metaphor. At other times you get lost just as he does in your own thoughts, inspired by his art. I came away with a cup full of love, deep thoughts and overall gratitude that I’d gotten a chance to see him in such an intimate venue.
If you get a chance to see this guy in concert, don’t miss it.




