What about the album before a band breaks big – can that album be good? In the case of this next band, the answer is yes.
But before we get there, as this is review #1971, here are three great records from the year 1971 for those interested in unrelated things that somehow seem related…
- The Who, “Who’s Next” (Disc 204)
- Led Zeppelin, “IV” (Disc 342)
- Alice Cooper, “Love It to Death” (Disc 604)
Disc 1971 is…All Over the Place
Artist: The Bangles
Year of Release: 1984
What’s up with the Cover? The band hangs out in what might charitably be called a “warehouse style apartment” and what might uncharitably be called simply a warehouse.
Whatever the case they’ve taken over, even having brought in what I presume to be one of those couches that lazy people leave on the side of the road.
Most such furniture just end up on a landfill, but this couch caught the attention of the Bangles. So too did a steel chair, which seems to have attracted the affection of singer and guitarist Susanna Hoffs, who is – literally - sitting pretty.
Particularly observant readers will note that, like Gaston, the Bangles use antlers in all of their decorating.
How I Came To Know It: I discovered the Bangles the way most of the world did, through their 1986 album “Different Light”. This was me digging backwards in their collection years later.
How It Stacks Up: I have two of the Bangles five albums. They are both solid and equal but different. However, this section is not designed for equivocators, so I’ll reluctantly take a stand and put “All Over the Place” in second place.
Ratings: 3 stars
Before they walked like an Egyptian, and before they lamented Mondays, the Bangles were an obscure American pop band trying to make it big. “All Over the Place” never hit top 40 in North America, but that’s more of an indictment of the fickle nature of hit making in pop music, than anything negative about the record. In fact, this record is sneaky good, and my only regret is that teenage me had to wait several decades to discover it.
A band’s first record can sometimes be disjointed as they explore just what ‘sound’ they are going to settle on. While it’s true that “All Over the Place” is a bit, well, all over the place, that’s part of its charm. The record blends eighties radio pop with New Wave and several earlier influences that felt like fifties and sixties pop somewhere between Buddy Holly and the Shangri-Las, with maybe a bit of late sixties psychedelia thrown in for good measure.
The New Wave element reveals itself in songs that jump the beat and infuse the record with a restless energy. Notable in this regard is “James,” which has a lively guitar lick and Hoffs’ vocals at their most playful.
While Hoffs is the person we think of as the Bangles lead singer, there are actually several talented singers in the band, and on their first record they each get their turn. Alongside Hoffs we have sisters Vicki (lead guitar) and Debbi (drums) Peterson taking their turns. Bands with even one strong vocalist aren’t easy to find, and the Bangles have three that can hold their own. This also allows a lot of great harmonies. The variety helps give the record range, although Hoffs vocals are the most distinctive and duskiest.
“Dover Beach” is Hoffs at her best, lilting her way through a late sixties inspired trip, accompanied by Vicki Peterson channeling her inner George Harrison on guitar. The influences on “All Over the Place” aren’t hard to place, but they are applied joyfully and with skill.
The band also has a unique ability to find just the right cover songs for their sound. On this record there are two, the best of which is “Going Down to Liverpool.” Is this version better than the Katrina &the Waves original? Reader it is not, but it is ever bit its equal, and that’s saying something.
The record is full of furiously played three-minute ditties, and is all over in just thirty minutes, well before it ever has a chance to settle down into itself. This is a positive, however, as that restless joyful energy is a big part of the Bangles’ allure. While there are places where the collection of songs lacks an overall focus at the “album” scale, that also kind of fits the overall vibe, making it easy to forgive.
Best tracks: Hero Takes a Fall, James, Dover Beach, Going Down to Liverpool


